Good Decision-Making – Part 2

In my last posting, we explored the business of decision-making.  Great leaders know how to make decisions logically and in a timely manner.

In post #1, I suggested that good decision making requires:

  • Solid research
  • A good evaluation of all the options
  • Decisiveness

A recent article by Har­vey Schachter offers two more decision making tips:

  • “Don’t get hung up in your views of how things “should” be be­cause you will miss out learn­ing how they re­ally are.”
  • “…re­mem­ber that you’re look­ing for the best an­swer overall, not sim­ply the best an­swer you can come up with your­self.”

Both tips suggest we need to work out our decisions in a group, consulting with others and coming up with a consensus.  But many will argue that this process can be stifling, time consuming and often lead us down a path that is too safe, too normal and possibly wrong.

It is very hard to satisfy everyone all the time. And the more you suggest that everyone has a say in the decision, the more you will leave a part of your audience very disappointed.

And so, Mr. Schachter ­did some digging and came up with a policy from the Creo Prod­ucts Ltd. employee handbook.

“Employ­ees were treated as pres­i­dents of their own work: If the de­ci­sion was small, af­fect­ing only the de­ci­sion maker, or if a quick de­ci­sion was needed, they were in­structed to de­cide on their own. If the num­ber of peo­ple af­fected was small but the im­pact large, con­sen­sus was ad­vised, with ev­ery­one fol­low­ing an ‘I can live with this’ rule. If the im­pact was small but the num­ber of peo­ple af­fected large, decisions were to be made demo­crat­i­cally with the ma­jor­ity rul­ing. If the de­ci­sion’s im­pact was large and the num­ber of peo­ple af­fected was also large, a small group should be formed to ham­mer out a con­sen­sus, with in­put from all af­fected share­hold­ers.”

“That fo­cuses on the sit­u­a­tion,” he goes on to say, “im­pact and peo­ple af­fected – rather than the bril­liance of one in­di­vid­ual”.

Having said all of that, leaders need to make decisions effectively. If it requires group input, it should be obvious to the leader. If it requires a single-minded, stand-alone approach – this should also be clear. 

Leadership is not easy.  Neither is decision making.  Maybe this will help.


More Posts

Working with a Disengaged Team

I have been watching a friend struggle recently as she tries to manage a team of people who were not engaged.  Read… ‘they really didn’t care’.  The result is demoralizing

Now is the Time to Find Your Coach

Well, actually it was time to find your coach a long time ago. But that’s alright.  There’s still time. They figured out many moons ago that professional athletes needed coaches.

Subscribe to my blog

Leave a Reply

Scroll to Top